What if the food supplier sends different products than what we ordered?

Date modified: 22nd September 2025 | This FAQ page has been written by Pilla Founder, Liam Jones, click to email Liam directly, he reads every email. Or book a demo to see how hospitality businesses use Pilla to manage food safety.

When suppliers substitute products, it's crucial that they clearly indicate these changes in writing - verbal notifications are not acceptable. Any product substitutions must be mutually agreed upon and communicated via email or written documentation. This is particularly important for allergen management, as your allergen files and matrix may need to be updated.

If you receive products that don't match your order specifications, you should reject them and contact the supplier immediately. Make sure to clearly label any rejected items as "not for consumption" and store them in a designated area for disposal or return.

Common misunderstanding: If a supplier substitutes a product with a similar item, it's not necessary to update allergen records since the items are alike.

Even if a substituted product seems similar, it may contain different allergens or be produced in a facility with other allergen protocols. It is essential to update allergen records with every substitution to prevent potential health risks and ensure compliance with food safety regulations.

Common misunderstanding: Verbal agreements about product substitutions are sufficient if there is a good relationship with the supplier.

Relying on verbal agreements can lead to misunderstandings and lacks the accountability of written documentation. For legal and operational clarity, it's crucial to have all substitutions documented in writing to protect both parties and ensure smooth operations.

What if we notice the wrong items after the delivery driver has left?

If you discover incorrect items after the delivery inspection, you should immediately label these items "not for consumption" and store them in a designated area away from other products. Contact your supplier right away to arrange returns or replacements.

Common misunderstanding: Once the delivery driver leaves, it's too late to rectify any errors with the delivery.

Even after the delivery driver has left, you still have the right and responsibility to address any discrepancies. Promptly documenting the error and contacting the supplier allows for resolution through returns or replacements, maintaining quality and safety standards.

Common misunderstanding: Incorrect items don't need to be segregated if they won't be used.

Incorrect items should always be segregated and labeled "not for consumption" to prevent accidental use and cross-contamination. This practice ensures food safety and operational integrity.

Should we still check temperatures of incorrect items?

Yes, even if items are incorrect, you should still check and record their temperatures at delivery. For chilled foods, they should ideally be below 5°C (maximum 8°C), and frozen foods should be at -18°C (maximum -15°C). This information might be important when discussing the delivery issues with your supplier, and it's essential for maintaining your food safety records.

Common misunderstanding: Temperature checks are unnecessary for incorrect deliveries since they won't be used.

Conducting temperature checks on all deliveries, correct or incorrect, is vital for maintaining a comprehensive food safety record. This information is crucial when discussing issues with suppliers and can help identify trends that may indicate broader systemic issues.

Common misunderstanding: Recording temperatures of incorrect items is only necessary if you plan to return them.

Recording temperatures is essential regardless of your intention to return items. This practice supports food safety compliance and can provide valuable data during supplier negotiations or audits.

UK Official Guidance

USA Official Guidance

Have a different question and can't find the answer you're looking for? Reach out to our founder Liam Jones, click to email Liam directly, he reads every email.

How do I know if poultry is fresh when it arrives from a supplier?

To ascertain the freshness of poultry upon delivery, check for the following attributes: The skin should be creamy in colour and free from blemishes or bruises.

How do I know if meat is fresh when it arrives from a supplier?

To determine if meat is fresh upon delivery, look for these signs of freshness: (1) An even red/brown colour on all meat surfaces. (2) Moistness to the touch but not slimy.

What temperature should frozen deliveries be when they arrive?

Frozen deliveries should arrive at a temperature of -18°C or colder, up to a maximum of -15°C.

How do I know if fish is fresh when it arrives from a supplier?

To determine the freshness of fish upon delivery, look for several key indicators: Bright, not sunken eyes; firm flesh with a fine layer of sea slime; red-coloured gills; scales that are difficult to remove and appear fresh, not dry; and a neutral to slightly oceanic smell without strong fishy odours. Additionally, fish can be considered fresh if it is flash-frozen immediately after catch and properly thawed, as quick freezing preserves its quality.

How do I know if vegetables are fresh when it arrives from a supplier?

To assess the freshness of vegetables delivered from a supplier, check for firmness, absence of mold, a fresh smell, and an absence of blemishes, bruising, or discolouration.

How quickly do I need to put food deliveries away?

Food deliveries should be transferred from the delivery point to storage areas within 15 minutes, including the time needed for unboxing.

What should I do if chilled food arrives above 8°C from a supplier?

If chilled food arrives above 8°C from a supplier, you must immediately reject the delivery and inform the supplier. This temperature exceeds the critical food safety limit of 8°C.

Do I need to keep delivery paperwork from food suppliers?

Yes, retaining all delivery notes and invoices from your food suppliers is essential.

What should I check on tins when they arrive from a food supplier?

When receiving tins from a food supplier, inspect for these key points: (1) Ensure there is no rust on the tins, as it may indicate compromised metal integrity.

Can I accept food from a supplier that's close to its use-by date?

No, you should not accept deliveries that are close to their use-by dates. Ensure use-by dates have a minimum of 5 days remaining and best-before dates have at least 1 month remaining.

What if I find pest damage in a food delivery?

If you find pest damage in a food delivery, immediately reject the affected items.

Do I need to take temperatures between packages in food deliveries or can I pierce them?

You must always take temperatures between packs of food using a clean and sanitised probe. Never pierce the packaging to take a temperature as this can compromise food safety and product integrity.

If frozen food looks partially defrosted, can I still accept the food delivery?

No, you should reject any frozen deliveries that show signs of defrosting or refreezing, as they can seriously affect food quality through freezer burn when the product is refrozen.

What's the minimum use-by date we should accept on a food delivery?

For food deliveries, ensure that products have at least 5 days of usage remaining on their use-by dates.