What red flags should I watch for in a Restaurant Assistant Manager job interview?

Date modified: 17th January 2025 | This FAQ page has been written by Pilla Founder, Liam Jones, click to email Liam directly, he reads every email.

Watch for poor leadership presence, inability to handle management pressure, and resistance to business coordination whilst focusing on management-critical behaviours. Identify concerning patterns affecting team development and operational excellence.

Common misunderstanding: Minor issues don't indicate management problems.

Many hiring managers dismiss small behavioural warning signs during interviews. They fail to recognise that leadership-critical behaviours reveal serious management concerns requiring careful evaluation.

Let's say you are an assistant manager interviewing candidates. A candidate interrupts you twice and dismisses team input during role-play scenarios. These behaviours signal potential leadership problems and poor management presence.

Common misunderstanding: All interview behaviours are equally important.

Some managers treat minor nervousness the same as serious leadership concerns. They fail to distinguish between normal interview stress and genuine management capability problems.

Let's say you are an assistant manager evaluating candidates. Nervous stammering differs from aggressive responses to feedback. Focus on behaviours that indicate professional management reliability and leadership capability under pressure.

How do I identify concerning behaviours during a Restaurant Assistant Manager interview?

Observe management authority issues, aggressive pressure responses, and communication problems during leadership trials whilst noting professional management behaviour patterns. Look for behaviours indicating leadership reliability concerns.

Common misunderstanding: Single incidents don't reveal character.

Hiring managers often overlook concerning behaviour patterns by focusing on isolated incidents. They miss repeated management authority issues and poor pressure responses that predict leadership failure.

Let's say you are an assistant manager observing interview behaviour. Notice if candidates consistently blame others, avoid responsibility, or show poor communication skills across multiple questions and scenarios.

Common misunderstanding: Leadership issues will improve with training.

Some managers minimise serious leadership problems, believing training will fix fundamental management issues. They fail to recognise core professional behaviours that indicate management unsuitability.

Let's say you are an assistant manager considering a candidate who shows poor conflict resolution skills and defensive responses. These fundamental leadership traits rarely improve through basic training and indicate management unsuitability.

What warning signs indicate a poor Restaurant Assistant Manager candidate fit?

Notice team development avoidance, business coordination resistance, and strategic thinking limitations whilst evaluating professional management attitudes. Identify patterns suggesting operational problems and leadership concerns.

Common misunderstanding: Good technical skills override behaviour concerns.

Hiring managers sometimes ignore warning signs because candidates show strong technical restaurant knowledge. They fail to assess management fit through comprehensive behaviour observation and leadership scenarios.

Let's say you are an assistant manager impressed by someone's food safety knowledge. However, they show poor team coordination and resistance to feedback. Technical skills don't compensate for fundamental management behaviour problems.

Common misunderstanding: Experience compensates for behavioural red flags.

Some managers overlook warning signs because candidates have impressive experience. They fail to recognise that management success requires specific behavioural competencies regardless of background.

Let's say you are an assistant manager reviewing someone with 10 years' experience who shows poor team development attitudes. Experience doesn't guarantee leadership effectiveness if fundamental management behaviours are problematic.